Charlottetown’s heritage homes have a champion

From its modest exterior of dark red wooden cladding, it would be easy to dismiss the small house in Charlottetown, P.E.I.’s historic downtown Hillsborough district as cute, but insignificant.
Under that cladding, however, is an historic log house built in 1844 – making it the third oldest known log home in the city. It was also at the centre of a controversy that saw it damaged and nearly razed by its previous owner who was rebelling against an historic designation that brought with it tight controls on renovations.
Then-owner Ray Campbell was so determined to get his way with the city that he deliberately made a hole in the house’s roof, and took a chain saw to some of the logs at the house’s corners in the hope it would collapse. Apoplectic city officials threatened heavy fines if Campbell continued.
Then, three years ago, Paul Coles stepped in.
Coles runs a small heritage home renovation business. In addition to doing work for clients, he has bought, renovated and sold about 20 properties in Charlottetown over the past two decades. So, when he heard the old log cabin was in peril, he stepped forward and offered to buy it in 2018. Not as an investment, but to be his own home.
“The previous owner was an anti-establishment drama guy,” says Paul, grinning as he recalled the difficult negotiations to take over the cherished house. “I’ve bought and sold some 20 properties; this was the worst closing I’ve ever had.”

STORY CONTINUES BELOW GALLERY

It was also a sign of the challenge Coles, 55, faced as he planned how to restore the building, while adding modern conveniences. He started by bringing in a friend who was an expert in restoring logs, and who is knowledgeable in dendrochronology – determining a log’s age by studying its rings.
That friend cleaned and refinished the logs, and replaced the ancient chinking with modern material.
Coles decided to expose the log walls in the inside while adding insulation and wiring on the outside of the building, covered by new wood cladding. While some purists object to not seeing logs on the outside, Coles says it was common 100-plus years ago to cover the exterior to prevent the logs from rotting.
ConnecTour was given a tour of the nearly complete project during a recent stopover in Prince Edward Island’s capital city. Because the house was moved one lot east onto an uneven foundation in 1923, it has a distinct tilt to it. One corner of the house sits a full 15 centimetres lower than the far corner, Coles says.
“At the end of the day, I wish I had disassembled the whole house and built a new foundation,” he says.
Renovations included replacing the rear half of the roof to add more room on the second floor, adding a steel beam to reinforce the structure and replacing the joists under the entire main floor. Tiled sections of the floor have in-floor heating. Still, much of the home’s original charm remains, including the worn pine floor boards on the second floor.
The kitchen area has been opened up, but – as with much of the house – materials from other houses have been repurposed to keep the time-period feel. The kitchen cabinets, for example, are clad in wainscotting taken from an old church, and a reclaimed window on an interior wall overlooks the staircase.
The exposed logs display the craftsmanship of the time, says Coles, when there were no mass-produced nails to hold the structure together. Instead, the structure is held together through wooden pegs and dovetail joints.
The central chimney – which once vented a large hearth – has a tilt of about 10 degrees. Coles says tilting chimneys were common at the time, built so the chimney exited at the roof’s peak.
Part of the home’s charm is the district it’s located in. As recently as 20 years ago, it was a notorious bootlegging part of the city until a local MLA drove the charge for a crackdown on the illegal activity.
“Ten years ago, no one wouldn’t come down these streets,” says Jennifer Keenan, a friend and neighbour of Coles.
Coles has won eight City of Charlottetown Heritage Awards for his restoration work, which includes another nearby house that dates to 1810. It’s not the only old things he appreciates: Coles also has a 1952 Studebaker pickup truck, and original Datsun (now Nissan) 240Z sports car and Corvette Stingray, both from 1993.

The ConnecTour team is heading to Nova Scotia, Cape Breton and then to Newfoundland in the last segment of their journey. Watch for updates.